Share:

You Don't Own Your Reputation, You Rent It.

Nick Ridley • 22/06/2020

It is clear that a number of real estate occupiers are withholding rent despite having the cash to pay. This isn’t just a moral issue; it is a systemic threat. 

Goodwill is creating the flexibility needed to manage today’s cash crisis. Many tenants, landlords and lenders are working together to manage their cashflows. Everyone is looking for some breathing space. But undermining that goodwill will create distrust. 

'If they don’t pay, why should I?'

We saw how fast distrust spread among banks in the global financial crisis. It caused liquidity to evaporate in that sector with consequences for the wider economy that were unthinkable at the time. We shouldn’t forget how entrenched the real estate industry is in the economy or the financial sector. Even our pensions directly or indirectly rely on rent cashflows. 

And so, we shouldn’t underestimate how quickly distrust created by ‘can pay, won’t pay’ occupiers could worsen today’s cash crisis and start a chain of events that are inevitable in their impact. 

Code of Honour

In response to this threat, the Government has formed a working group with organisations in the commercial rental sector such as the British Property Federation and Revo. 

Following discussions with the group, the Government has announced its plans to publish a Code of Practice for retail, leisure and hospitality businesses and landlords before the June payment day (24 June). 

The draft code as highlighted in the industry press over the past week indicated ‘…not the intention of this code to undermine of alter the basis of the legal relationship of existing lease contracts…’ Further to this the statements that ‘tenants who are in a position to pay in full should do so…(others) should pay what they can…landlords should support affected businesses where they can afford it.’  

All eminently sensible but it has to be said, ambiguous. ‘Tenants in a position to pay in full’ and ‘landlords who can afford it:’ who is to determine this? Are tenants and landlords going to be judged against guidance to ‘provide relevant financial information’ if concessions are sought by tenants or denied by landlords? The suggestion of a third-party mediator does sound sensible as long as the right companies are used to facilitate this. 

The largest omission, which there is still time to add to the final paper, is for the Government to underwrite rents. 

The Code looks to encourage 'fair and transparent discussions between landlords and tenants over rental payments during the coronavirus pandemic and guidance on rent arrear payments and treatment of sub-letter and suppliers.' This has the intention to promote collaboration within the sector and ensure no one part of the chain shoulders the full burden of payment. It is also likely to stress the importance of service charge and insurance payments in full. 

The Code will be a temporary and voluntary framework. This ensures contractual arrangements take precedent and allows stakeholders the flexibility to work out their problems case-by-case. But the Code’s voluntary status also risks it not fixing the problem it needs to solve – if ‘can’t pay, won’t pay’ tenants are ignoring their contractual obligations, why would they follow voluntary guidance? 

As a hint of what may come, the Government has already said it will make the Code mandatory if necessary. 

Dues Paid 

Last quarter’s rent collection rates were bad enough to spark talk of systemic risk and Government intervention: but how bad were they? 

Property managers collect 80% of rent on the due date in a normal quarter. But collection rates in the March quarter were at historic lows, down 30 percentage points on average for all property types. Retail properties’ rates had halved. 

Lockdown started only 2 days before rent was due – close enough for businesses to have a full quarter of trading behind them but so close that the full effects of trading under lockdown were still unknown and many rental transfers had already completed. 

The knee-jerk reaction for many businesses was to delay rent payment. As lockdown progressed, the fortunes of businesses in different sectors diverged. Weak trading confirmed many tenants’ fears and retail and leisure sectors felt the most pain, leaving their rent collection rates depressed. Those with retail portfolios – such as Intu and Hammerson, had much lower collection rates compared to the 80% on offices.

Rent Collection Rates for March Quarter Day UK

Source: Remit Consulting

Meanwhile, office-using businesses have kept productivity high thanks to remote working and logistics firms are overcoming their supply chain issues. Rent collection rates improved by around 30 percentage points between the due date and 49 days after the due date for office and industrial properties. For comparison, retail only improved 18 percentage points over the same period. 

Although the Government is consulting with the retail, leisure and hospitality sectors, the Code needs to apply to all property types. Low rent collection rates are an industry-wide challenge. 

More Pain 

Low rent collection rates will not be a one-off event. We expect further challenges at June quarter and collection rates are very likely to be worse than those seen in March.  

Our belief that collection rates will be lower this quarter is based on more than a hunch. A good guide for June comes from our experience of the 28 May Scottish Quarter day. We collected 45% of rents on the due date for the Scottish Quarter day from a mixed portfolio, but we also saw some leisure and food-and-beverage-led schemes with rent collection rates at low single digits. 

Despite ongoing issues, the industry should be incredibly proud of how it has coped since lockdown. Tenants have been under extreme pressure, but many have still been open and proactive with their landlords. In turn, landlords have granted monthly rents, deferrals, payment concessions and in some instances rent holidays for tenants. Likewise, lenders have shown that they can be flexible by restructuring facilities and giving borrowers payment holidays. 

Most stakeholders understand that avoiding reputational risk in an industry built on long-term relationships is essential. Others should keep in mind that reputations are not owned, they are rented. All stakeholders want to be part of the recovery, not in a state of financial distress when the recovery arrives. It is in no one’s interests to see swathes of empty premises on the other side of this pandemic.

Across all industries, people’s ability to feel comfortable, safe and secure will be paramount to business recovery. Organisations will need to help people return to open commerce with a sense of trust. At the same time, businesses and investors alike need trusted guidance to manage real estate in the current climate, and to predict what's next for the industry. Cushman & Wakefield is ready to help ensure they can do so with confidence.  
 

 

Latest articles in this series

Leeds North Star cafe closure COVID-19
Insights • Economy

Outlook for 2021: Small Prizes and Big Penalties

Long-term property investors should focus on location and asset quality, as those factors drive performance over a cycle. But, right or wrong, risk aversion to income risk tends to trump other factors in downturns and will dictate pricing trends in 2021. 
Greg Mansell • 04/11/2020
Westminster Bridge towards Houses of Parliament, London
Insights • Economy

Brexit Trade Negotiations and What They Mean for Businesses

Like COVID-19, Brexit has major implications for businesses across the country whatever the outcome of the negotiations. 
Richard Coleman • 04/11/2020
Ship with shipping containers
Insights • Retail

Retail & Supply Chain

2021 will continue to see growth in e-commerce and logistics demand and new retail supply chain models will be required to capitalise on the structural shifts in the sector.
Paul Durkin • 04/11/2020
Woman doing yoga next to home desk
Insights • Commentary

Locked Down and Locked In

What will happen in 2021? Perhaps there will be a vaccine, perhaps there won’t. Perhaps people will return to the office, perhaps they won’t. The smarter questions focus on what adaptions business and people will make over the coming year that set them on a new path for the future.
Richard Pickering • 04/11/2020
Technology 3D (image)
Insights • Technology

The Impact of Technology on Real Estate

Technology has created huge changes to the property markets and real estate industry in 2020. We asked Chris Hancocks from our Futures team, and Ross Hodges from our Global Innovation Hub what they see as the proptech to watch in 2021. 

Chris Hancocks • 04/11/2020
George Roberts Cushman & Wakefield
Insights • Commentary

How 2021 Might Reshape The Real Estate Industry

We will look back at 2020 as the year in which COVID-19 accelerated forces of change. These forces will shape the industry for many years to come and for those that are able to interpret and take advantage of them, the opportunities are enormous. 
George Roberts • 04/11/2020
Leeds North Star cafe closure COVID-19
Insights • Economy

Outlook for 2021: Small Prizes and Big Penalties

Long-term property investors should focus on location and asset quality, as those factors drive performance over a cycle. But, right or wrong, risk aversion to income risk tends to trump other factors in downturns and will dictate pricing trends in 2021. 
Greg Mansell • 04/11/2020
Leeds North Star cafe closure COVID-19
Insights • Economy

Outlook for 2021: Small Prizes and Big Penalties

Long-term property investors should focus on location and asset quality, as those factors drive performance over a cycle. But, right or wrong, risk aversion to income risk tends to trump other factors in downturns and will dictate pricing trends in 2021. 
Greg Mansell • 04/11/2020
older lady wearing glasses and iphone headphones looking at device
Insights

Defining The Retirement Living Sector

In partnership with The British Property Federation (BPF) this report looks at the UK undersupply of housing with care schemes, self-contained homes that have the capacity to provide care, yet allow residents to continue living independently.
Greg Mansell • 21/10/2020
Southwark station empty escalator
Insights • Economy

COVID-19 Impacts on UK Real Estate

A brief weekly update on the impacts of COVID-19 pandemic on commercial real estate in the UK.
Greg Mansell • 15/10/2020
Bank of England bank notes
Insights • Economy

The Crisis Playbook

Life was normal a month ago. There was a nagging feeling that COVID-19 could change all that, but it wasn’t a big concern. Since then, the unravelling of freedoms we might have taken for granted has been rapid. 
Greg Mansell • 24/03/2020
blurred horizon
Insights • Economy

The Attraction of Alternative Real Estate

In 2018 28% (£17bn) of all commercial real estate investment in the UK was in alternatives - hotels, student living, residential, healthcare, data centres, self-storage and car parks - the highest level on record. What is driving this alternative property investment market growth?
Greg Mansell • 11/07/2019
Data Center Update Web Card
Research • Data Center

EMEA Data Centre MarketBeats | Autumn/Winter

Development continues across the core FLAP-D markets in ever-larger phases as companies continue their move off-premises and operators expand their data centres accordingly. Many of the hyperscale services have chosen to launch new products and expansions in these areas first, reflecting continued and potential demand over the next several years.
Dave Fanning • 16/12/2020
elderly gentleman's hand place over each other on walking stick
Insights • Residential

Should You Invest in the Retirement Living Sector?

As a needs-based product, senior living real estate has historically proven to be more recession-resilient and stable than traditional real estate sectors.
Lee Layton • 14/12/2020
Business Rates
Insights • Occupier

Let's Talk Business Rates

In this 'Let’s Talk Business Rates' edition we provide an overview of the key events impacting business rates including; rate relief and several potential options to reduce your business rates liability.
14/12/2020
person drawing a chart in marker on glass
Insights • Investment

The EMEA Investor Update

An update on the impacts of COVID-19 pandemic on real estate investment in EMEA. 
James Young • 14/01/2021
workers in coworking space blurred man walking past seated women
Research • Coworking

Coworking Trends

We outline the difference between the offers, along with market leading research on coworking trends across the world.
17/11/2020
Woman doing yoga next to home desk
Insights • Commentary

Locked Down and Locked In

What will happen in 2021? Perhaps there will be a vaccine, perhaps there won’t. Perhaps people will return to the office, perhaps they won’t. The smarter questions focus on what adaptions business and people will make over the coming year that set them on a new path for the future.
Richard Pickering • 04/11/2020
George Roberts Cushman & Wakefield
Insights • Commentary

How 2021 Might Reshape The Real Estate Industry

We will look back at 2020 as the year in which COVID-19 accelerated forces of change. These forces will shape the industry for many years to come and for those that are able to interpret and take advantage of them, the opportunities are enormous. 
George Roberts • 04/11/2020
Ship with shipping containers
Insights • Retail

Retail & Supply Chain

2021 will continue to see growth in e-commerce and logistics demand and new retail supply chain models will be required to capitalise on the structural shifts in the sector.
Paul Durkin • 04/11/2020
red steel building
Insights • Commentary

UK Real Estate Perspectives

As the COVID-19 pandemic envelops the globe, we are committed to providing our clients with up to the minute intelligence and commentary as to what is happening in the real estate markets.
Digby Flower • 04/11/2020
Technology 3D (image)
Insights • Technology

The Impact of Technology on Real Estate

Technology has created huge changes to the property markets and real estate industry in 2020. We asked Chris Hancocks from our Futures team, and Ross Hodges from our Global Innovation Hub what they see as the proptech to watch in 2021. 

Chris Hancocks • 04/11/2020
dark haired woman sitting on desk talking to coworkers
Insights • Office

Coworking UK Report

Our latest report “Coworking 2020: What’s Next on the Flexible Workspace Horizon?” explores how the UK Flexible Workspace sector could help play a key role in the recovery after COVID-19.

15/10/2020
modern white empty office space
Insights • Occupier

The EMEA Occupier Update

An update on the impacts of COVID-19 pandemic on real estate occupiers in EMEA. 
James Maddock • 15/10/2020
Shoe shop front, Camden, London
Insights • Retail

UK Retail House View

The latest house view on the UK retail market.
Paul Durkin • 12/10/2020
Birmingham
Insights • Commentary

Planning Reform

A White Paper currently undergoing consultation will deliver the most significant overhaul of the English planning system since the introduction of the Town & Country Planning Act in 1947. As with any change there will inevitably be winners, losers and unintended consequences.
Andy Teage • 24/09/2020
Empty office modern clean
Insights • Occupier

What Next? The Future of Offices

The good news for the offices sector is that the hysteria appears to be dying down. Business leaders that were calling time on the office, now accept that they’ll continue to have an important role in future.
Ben Cullen • 23/09/2020
Kadine James Podcast (image)
Podcast • Technology

What's Next in Corporate Real Estate Podcast

Kadine James, Creative Tech Lead at Hobs 3D, discusses the influence that technology is having on property and how we do our jobs in better, more focused ways.
21/09/2020
Flexible Workspace
Insights • Coworking

Valuation of Flexible Workspace

With flexible workspace now considered a vital component of the workplace ecosystem, how should landlords successfully value a flexible workspace proposition?
10/09/2020
Data Center Update Web Card
Research • Data Center

Data Centre European Secondary Markets Report

Data centre development across Europe has long centred around what were first known as the FLAP markets, major global cities each with deep business and financial sectors. As these markets continue to thrive, a host of newer locations have joined the data centre landscape.
Dave Fanning • 12/08/2020
cyclist at UK train station holding newspaper with 5G ad
Insights • Public / Not-for-Profit

What is the Role of Local Government in Delivering Infrastructure?

A positive, mutually respectful, appropriately balanced relationship between local government, central government and the private sector is essential to the UK's recovery and could also produce positive, long term and overdue changes.
John Keyes • 29/07/2020
Warwick university
Insights • Education

The Future of Tertiary Education

Universities are facing an unprecedented shock. What happens in the next 3 months, and how well universities can adapt, will define the severity of impact of COVID-19 on the whole academic year 2020. 
Sarah Jones • 29/07/2020
woman leaping at Big Sur, California
Insights • Commentary

Is risk aversion more damaging than demand shock?

What does ‘risk’ actually mean? And do we have more to fear from these new risks themselves, or instead from the way that we choose to respond to them? 
Richard Pickering • 29/07/2020
London streets
Insights • Retail

A plea to retailers and landlords on turnover rents

It is really is tough out there and if you are working in leisure/F&B, that is another level of pain. From working with both retailers and landlords it is clear that neither realise how bad it is for the other. The current leasing model is broken, Covid-19 has just accelerated is demise. So, where do we go from here? 

Richard Ching • 15/07/2020
London tube
Insights • Commentary

Turning off the commute and redistributing value

Over the past two centuries, public transport, and in particular the train, has had a huge influence on how our cities have been shaped. Major infrastructure projects such as the Liverpool and Manchester Railway (1830) and the Metropolitan Railway (1863), joined cities together and facilitated the explosion of the suburbs.
Richard Pickering • 15/07/2020
Computer business
Insights • Commentary

Is work coming home

COVID-19 has significantly impacted how we work, live and play over recent months. Particularly the work and live elements have converged as people set up offices in the living room.  Looking forwards, what legacy might this create on where we live and how we adapt our homes to integrate more home working into our routine?  
Charles Whitworth • 15/07/2020
map with pins
Insights • Commentary

Location, environment and culture

Location, location, location, to steal the title of the eponymous long running Channel 4 series, is what it’s all about…or perhaps not. Coming out of lockdown location of course remains of critical importance, but perhaps not in the way you might think. Location in this context is very much about the location of people as opposed to property. 
Andrew Phipps • 15/07/2020
Data Center Update Web Card
Research • Data Center

EMEA Data Centre Update | Spring/Summer 2020

Many large operators have secured new investors for further expansion as the race to develop fully continental platforms continues.
Kevin Imboden • 13/07/2020
Shoreditch coffee house
Insights • Retail

Restarting F&B

Restarting hospitality is in all of our best interests: 25% of UK’s GDP drop in April was due to the hospitality sector being on hold. We review the creativity and challenges involved. 
Paul Durkin • 01/07/2020
Cranes, Stratford East London
Insights • Office

Is This End Of The Development Cycle?

The lockdown measures implemented by the Government to control the spread of coronavirus have had a profound effect on office development activity.
Patrick Scanlon • 01/07/2020
graph and numbers on blue screen
Insights • Investment

Will COVID-19 Affect Ownership Patterns for UK Real Estate?

Catalysts for distress, such as the COVID-19 pandemic, often lead to changes of ownership composition within the UK property market. Some investors see this distress as a buying opportunity whereas others will sell as assets re-price and risk perceptions alter. 
Jason Winfield • 01/07/2020
smartly dressed man with coffee
Insights • Commentary

Addressing the Widening Inequalities Created by Real Estate

How can the real estate industry start to tackle inequality? We work in an industry that is about creating wealth for investors, and this might seem like a diametric opposition to the challenge. However, it is worth remembering that today’s landowners are in effect you and me.
Richard Pickering • 22/06/2020

Related Services

Asset Services
Consistent across EMEA, to ensure buildings and people thrive.
Learn More
Valuation & Advisory

Giving you the confidence to make informed decisions.

Learn More
Capital Markets

Are you ready for what’s next in the real estate industry? Our Capital Markets team advises institutional and private owners, occupiers, investors and developers on their most significant transactions.

Learn More

CAN'T FIND WHAT YOU'RE LOOKING FOR?

Get in touch with one of our professionals.