Stories

The Palms Restaurants

A dispute between members of the families owning the Palm focused on improper transactions concerning the use of intellectual property (IP).

01 The Opportunity

A dispute between members of the families owning the Palm focused on improper transactions concerning the use of intellectual property (IP). First opened in 1929 by John Ganzi and Pio Bozzi, the restaurant started expanding in the ‘70’s under the direction of two members of a later generation – Bruce Bozzi Sr. and Walter Ganzi Jr. – and now operates approximately 25 restaurants throughout the U.S.

The Plaintiffs told the court that Bozzi Sr. and Ganzi Jr. caused Just One More Restaurant Corporation (JOMR), the entity that the families own together, to license the Palm IP at a below market rate. Each new restaurant paid a flat fee of $6,000 per year instead of a royalty calculated as a percentage of sales, which effectively cut the Minority Shareholder family members out of their rightful share of profits.

How do you determine a reasonable royalty rate? How much should be paid to license a well-known, 90-year-old business name and its trade dress (the signature look and feel of the product)? What is the proper structure for the payment of a licensing fee?

02 The Solution

The DALS team of Pamela O’Neill and David Benick prepared an expert report and delivered testimony that led to a groundbreaking ruling issued in the Supreme Court of the State of New York regarding the appropriate valuation method to calculate lost royalties.

Pam and David supported their reasonable royalty rate opinion for use of the Palm IP by examining a variety of qualitative factors and evaluating market evidence from the acquisitions of comparable premium steakhouse companies.

The Cushman & Wakefield team was able to present the analysis skillfully and persuasively. The Judge cited Pam as an “experienced valuation authority” and relied entirely on her analysis and testimony and declined to rely on the testimony and opinions of the valuation experts put forth by the Defendants. The Court found Pam’s testimony credible, her analysis of comparable steakhouse restaurants valid, and her assumptions and conclusions supported.

03 The Results

Based on the team’s findings, the judge awarded more than $116 million in lost royalties, rent and interest to our clients.

This result demonstrates the value of collaboration and our multi-disciplinary approach, which is the foundation of the DALS practice. The group has become a true litigation support practice with broad reach and capabilities in business valuation and damages extending beyond real estate related issues.

As the legal case law evolves in how best to assess damages when the appropriate royalty rate is in question, our team has helped set a legal precedent for matters involving disputes concerning intellectual property.

MEET THE TEAM

Pamela O'Neill

Managing Director
Chatham, United States

Pamela.Oneill@cushwake.com

Download VCard

David Benick

Managing Director
New York, United States

+1 (212) 8417723

David.Benick@cushwake.com

Download VCard

FEATURED SERVICES

Special Opportunities Group

Our team of 150 credit-trained professionals average 20 years of experience in US regulatory compliance, underwriting and diligence projects.

Learn More

Agency Leasing - Retail

Our Retail Agency Leasing experts create innovative solutions and maximum results to enhance your real estate investment’s value.

Learn More

Investor Services

Cushman & Wakefield’s Investor Services experts are your trusted advisors to help you drive performance and maximize your investment return.

Learn More

Valuation & Advisory

Our Valuation & Advisory (V&A) group of 640+ professionals across the Americas deliver clients accurate, reliable valuations that guide smart equity and debt decisions in real-time.

Learn More