Share: Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on LinkedIn I recommend visiting cushmanwakefield.com to read:%0A%0A {0} %0A%0A {1}
wine glasses (image) Restaurant glasses (image)

Stories

The Palms Restaurants

A dispute between members of the families owning the Palm focused on improper transactions concerning the use of intellectual property (IP).
 

01 The Opportunity

A dispute between members of the families owning the Palm focused on improper transactions concerning the use of intellectual property (IP). First opened in 1929 by John Ganzi and Pio Bozzi, the restaurant started expanding in the ‘70’s under the direction of two members of a later generation – Bruce Bozzi Sr. and Walter Ganzi Jr. – and now operates approximately 25 restaurants throughout the U.S.

 

The Plaintiffs told the court that Bozzi Sr. and Ganzi Jr. caused Just One More Restaurant Corporation (JOMR), the entity that the families own together, to license the Palm IP at a below market rate. Each new restaurant paid a flat fee of $6,000 per year instead of a royalty calculated as a percentage of sales, which effectively cut the Minority Shareholder family members out of their rightful share of profits.

 

How do you determine a reasonable royalty rate? How much should be paid to license a well-known, 90-year-old business name and its trade dress (the signature look and feel of the product)? What is the proper structure for the payment of a licensing fee?

02 The Solution

The DALS team of Pamela O’Neill and David Benick prepared an expert report and delivered testimony that led to a groundbreaking ruling issued in the Supreme Court of the State of New York regarding the appropriate valuation method to calculate lost royalties.

Pam and David supported their reasonable royalty rate opinion for use of the Palm IP by examining a variety of qualitative factors and evaluating market evidence from the acquisitions of comparable premium steakhouse companies.

The Cushman & Wakefield team was able to present the analysis skillfully and persuasively. The Judge cited Pam as an “experienced valuation authority” and relied entirely on her analysis and testimony and declined to rely on the testimony and opinions of the valuation experts put forth by the Defendants. The Court found Pam’s testimony credible, her analysis of comparable steakhouse restaurants valid, and her assumptions and conclusions supported.

03 The Results

Based on the team’s findings, the judge awarded more than $116 million in lost royalties, rent and interest to our clients.

This result demonstrates the value of collaboration and our multi-disciplinary approach, which is the foundation of the DALS practice. The group has become a true litigation support practice with broad reach and capabilities in business valuation and damages extending beyond real estate related issues.

As the legal case law evolves in how best to assess damages when the appropriate royalty rate is in question, our team has helped set a legal precedent for matters involving disputes concerning intellectual property.

MEET THE TEAM

Pamela O'Neill Headshot
Pamela O'Neill

Managing Director
New York, United States


Download VCard

David Benick New York Managing Director
David Benick

Managing Director
New York, United States


+1 (212) 8417723

Download VCard

FEATURED STORIES

Global Cities Americas Card
Research • Retail

Americas

Need information for your retail strategy beyond Fifth Avenue in New York or where to find luxury goods in San Francisco? Learn more in our Americas Global Cities Retail Guides.
generic-building-1
Research • Valuation

Figuring out Actual Returns in Today’s Commercial Property Markets

2018 was a strong year for Australian Commercial Real Estate with yields in many sectors and markets reaching record lows. While the current 2019 outlook shows some risk issues emerging, Australian commercial real estate yields remain relatively attractive compared to interest rates, bonds and many offshore property markets.
Robert Timmermans • 9/6/2019
2019 US Industrial Construction Map
Research • Industrial

Industrial Construction Map

Use Cushman & Wakefield's interactive map to find out how much industrial commercial real estate construction activity is taking place in select United States cities.
4/6/2022
Niche Asset Card Image
Research • Insights

Niche Assets

Transaction activity for niche assets—healthcare, cold storage, data centers and senior and student housing—has exploded in recent years.
David Bitner • 10/21/2019
Cool Streets Card Image
Research • Retail

2019 Cool Streets

The 18-Hour Cool Street is driven by persistent urban renewal. Though “upstart” neighborhoods in some markets were unexpected, the trend will continue.
10/8/2019

FEATURED SERVICES

2019 US Industrial Construction Map
Research • Industrial

Industrial Construction Map

Use Cushman & Wakefield's interactive map to find out how much industrial commercial real estate construction activity is taking place in select United States cities.
4/6/2022
Niche Asset Card Image
Research • Insights

Niche Assets

Transaction activity for niche assets—healthcare, cold storage, data centers and senior and student housing—has exploded in recent years.
David Bitner • 10/21/2019
Cool Streets Card Image
Research • Retail

2019 Cool Streets

The 18-Hour Cool Street is driven by persistent urban renewal. Though “upstart” neighborhoods in some markets were unexpected, the trend will continue.
10/8/2019
card image
Research • Retail

Pop-up-a-Palooza!

2019 was the year that the pop-up store "popped out." Digital natives going bricks-and-mortar; an explosion of local entrepreneurism; the rise of upstart brands; a new launching pad for global retailers, and so much more.
12/10/2019
Multifamily Update Card Image
Research • Multifamily

Multifamily Update: Class B Assets Emerging as Early Outperformer

The CARES Act has proven to effectively buoy the multifamily sector. Class B assets are emerging as an early outperformer and the “goldilocks” in this bear market.
Kristina Garcia • 7/24/2020
Sublease Space 2020 (image)
Research • Office

Office Space for Sublease | Q4 2021

In this report we take a close look at the amount of sublease space available in markets across the United States and Canada.
Sandy Romero • 2/3/2022
Supply Chain (image)
Research • Logistics

Expert Panel: Transforming the Supply Chain for Growing Digital Sales Demand

Listen to our latest panel of logistics and retail experts as they discuss the impacts of changing consumer behaviors on e-commerce supply chains. How has the extreme growth of digital sales impacted fulfillment?
Barrie Scardina • 10/21/2020
US Office Leasing trends Q1 2021 (image)
Research • Office

U.S. Office Leasing Market Trends: Has the Tide Turned Yet?

Cushman & Wakefield Research answer 15 questions occupiers and investors are asking about the U.S. office sector. Topics include building occupancy, office space demand, sublease space, rents, businesses relocating from CBDs and more.
David Smith • 12/2/2021
NY_NJ_Ports_Report_First_Half_2021_Generic_Card_750x456
Research

Port of New York & New Jersey H1 Report

The Port of NY/NJ has recorded substantial surges in cargo volume handled as national and local economies recover from the pandemic. Will the delta variant temper this trend?
Jason Price • 8/31/2021
Vital Signs Urgent Care Surge Image
Research • Medical

Vital Signs: Urgent Care

The number of urgent care centers has increased by 44% in the past five years.  Vital Signs Urgent Care Surge explores the growth and future of this sector.
Lorie Damon • 8/7/2019
Stock Market
Research • Economy

Global Macro Forecast

The report analyzes multiple factors contributing to economic slowdown and what they mean for property markets around the world.
Kevin Thorpe • 6/11/2019
2019 Holiday Shopping Recap Card
Research • Retail

Five Fast Facts: 2019 Holiday Shopping Season Recap

See where shoppers and retailers netted out in their quest for gifts and sales via bricks-and-mortar, online and everything in between in our compilation of Five Fast Facts: 2019 Holiday Shopping Season Recap!
Benjamin Conwell • 2/18/2020

INSIGHTS

Research • Industrial

US Industrial Construction Report Map

4/6/2022

Research • Insights

Niche Assets

David Bitner • 10/21/2019

Research • Retail

2019 Cool Streets

10/8/2019

NEWS

Research • Industrial

US Industrial Construction Report Map

4/6/2022

Research • Insights

Niche Assets

David Bitner • 10/21/2019

Research • Retail

2019 Cool Streets

10/8/2019

Research • Retail

Pop-up-a-Palooza!

12/10/2019

CAN'T FIND WHAT YOU'RE LOOKING FOR?

Get in touch with one of our professionals.

With your permission we and our partners would like to use cookies in order to access and record information and process personal data, such as unique identifiers and standard information sent by a device to ensure our website performs as expected, to develop and improve our products, and for advertising and insight purposes.

Alternatively click on More Options and select your preferences before providing or refusing consent. Some processing of your personal data may not require your consent, but you have a right to object to such processing.

You can change your preferences at any time by returning to this site or clicking on  Cookies

More Options
Agree and Close
These cookies ensure that our website performs as expected,for example website traffic load is balanced across our servers to prevent our website from crashing during particularly high usage.
These cookies allow our website to remember choices you make (such as your user name, language or the region you are in) and provide enhanced features. These cookies do not gather any information about you that could be used for advertising or remember where you have been on the internet.
These cookies allow us to work with our marketing partners to understand which ads or links you have clicked on before arriving on our website or to help us make our advertising more relevant to you.
Agree All
Reject All
SAVE SETTINGS